As the AFL season crosses its halfway mark, the buzz around the All-Australian team is reaching a fever pitch. But let’s be honest—this isn’t just about who’s had a good run of games; it’s a snapshot of the league’s evolving identity. Personally, I think what makes this year’s conversation so fascinating is how it reflects broader trends in the sport: the rise of versatile players, the enduring value of experience, and the relentless push for innovation in team structures.
Take the defenders, for instance. James Sicily, Harris Andrews, and Nick Blakey aren’t just names on a list—they’re symbols of the modern defender’s role. Andrews, in my opinion, is the gold standard for key defenders, but Blakey’s ability to rebound and play taller roles is a game-changer. What many people don’t realize is that Blakey’s versatility is a microcosm of how teams are redefining defensive roles. It’s not just about stopping the opposition anymore; it’s about launching attacks.
Tom McCartin’s inclusion at centre-half-back is another intriguing choice. His season has been admirable, but what this really suggests is that consistency and reliability still matter in a league obsessed with flashiness. Averaging 20.1 disposals and 7.4 marks per game? That’s not just stats—that’s a player who’s doing the grunt work while others grab the headlines.
In the midfield, Bailey Smith’s selection is a hot topic. Personally, I think his ball use gets unfairly criticized. Yes, it’s not always perfect, but his territory gain and work rate are unparalleled. If you take a step back and think about it, Smith embodies the modern midfielder: not just a ball magnet, but a player who controls space.
Isaac Heeney, on the other hand, is having a career year. What makes him particularly fascinating is his dual-threat capability. Averaging 2.0 goals per game as a midfielder? That’s not just impressive—it’s revolutionary. In my opinion, Heeney is redefining what a midfielder can be, and it’s a trend we’ll see more of in the coming years.
Jordan Dawson’s inclusion is both a sporting and human story. Performing at an elite level while dealing with personal tragedy is nothing short of extraordinary. What this really suggests is that courage isn’t just about on-field heroics; it’s about resilience in the face of adversity.
Up forward, Josh Treacy’s dominance as a power forward is undeniable. But what’s often overlooked is how he’s thriving in a league that’s increasingly favoring smaller, quicker forwards. In my opinion, Treacy’s success is a reminder that there’s still a place for the traditional key forward—if they’re good enough.
Jack Gunston’s continued excellence at 35 is another standout. What many people don’t realize is that his ability to adapt his game has kept him relevant. He’s not the same player he was a decade ago, but he’s still one of the best at what he does.
The followers—Max Gawn, Marcus Bontempelli, and Zak Butters—are a masterclass in longevity and potential. Gawn, at 35, is still the benchmark for ruckmen. Bontempelli, meanwhile, is on track for his best season yet. Butters, though, is the wildcard. His performance amid speculation about his future is a testament to his mental toughness.
The interchange bench is where the real debates happen. Nick Daicos, despite his kicking efficiency issues, is still a force. But what this really suggests is that even the best players have flaws—and that’s okay. Luke Jackson’s inclusion over Brodie Grundy is a bold call, but it highlights the value of versatility in the modern game.
If you take a step back and think about it, this All-Australian team isn’t just a list of the best players; it’s a reflection of where the game is headed. The rise of dual-threat players, the enduring value of experience, and the increasing importance of versatility are all on full display.
One thing that immediately stands out is how this team balances youth and experience. It’s not just about who’s hot right now; it’s about who’s consistently great. And that, in my opinion, is what makes the All-Australian team such a compelling conversation.
What this really suggests is that the AFL is in a period of transition. The old guard is still holding its own, but the new wave is knocking on the door. It’s a delicate balance, and it’s what makes this season—and this team—so exciting.
So, as we debate the inclusions and omissions, let’s remember: this isn’t just about individual brilliance. It’s about the story of a sport evolving, adapting, and redefining itself. And that, personally, is what makes this All-Australian team so much more than a list of names.
